Decision ref
0035 2026/27
Decision date
20/11/2026
Portfolio
Regeneration, Property & Planning
Wards
All wards
Title
Confirmation of Article 4 direction for HMO's
Summary
Confirmation of a borough wide Article 4(1) Direction for the removal of permitted development rights for the change of use from Use Class C3 (dwelling houses) to C4 (Small HMOs), following Cabinets decision on 20th July, and a public consultation on the proposed Direction.
Purpose
Following Cabinet' decision on the 20th July to impose an Article 4(1) Direction for the removal of permitted development rights for the change of use from Use Class C3 (dwelling houses) to C4 (Small HMOs), on a boroughwide basis, and in accordance with the Cabinet resolution, Planning Services undertook a 7-week public consultation on the proposal. In deciding whether confirm a Direction made under Article 4(1), the local planning authority must take into account any representations received during a consultation period specified in accordance with the legislation. Consultation was carried out via:
• Site notices were placed in every designated town, district and local centre in the borough.
• A notice was placed in the St Helens Star.
• A copy of the order and plan of the borough were made available to be viewed at reasonable hours at St Helens Town Hall and on the Council website.
• The Council’s social media channels made a post about the consultation, where documents could be viewed and comments submitted.
The Council received 33 written responses to the consultation:
• 12 were in support of the Article 4 Direction,
• 19 objected to the Article 4 Direction
• 2 representations were received which related to a specific HMO planning application under consideration and raised concerns with parking and highway impacts, but these are not considered to be material to the Article 4 Direction.
This report considers the representations received and addresses the comments received.
Background
The points raised in the representations in support of the Article 4 Direction are summarised as follows:
• General support for requiring planning permission for new HMOs and the greater control this offers.
• Greater opportunity for community involvement.
• Protection of residential amenity.
• Concerns with the impact of HMOs on community cohesion.
• Financial considerations should not override community interests.
• Recognition of the need for affordable and flexible housing.
• Future applications for HMOs should be based on evidence of the impacts gathered from local residents.
• Opportunity to limit the number of HMO’s to allow more people to become homeowners
• HMO’s can have impacts on parking, noise nuisance and surrounding property values.
Considering the above points raised in the 12 representations in support of the Article 4 Direction, officers would advise that the greater control the Article 4 Direction would provide is acknowledged in the original cabinet report. The Article 4 Direction would require HMOs for between 3-6 residents to now require planning permission and would enable the Local Planning Authority (LPA) to consider issues such as amenity impacts for neighbouring and future residents, over concentration of HMOs impacting the character of an area, parking and highway impacts etc. The requirement for these HMOs to require planning permission would also mean neighbouring residents are consulted on these applications and given the opportunity to submit their views on these and for these to be considered when assessing the applications. The potential financial impacts and compensation claims were noted in the report to Cabinet on the proposed Article 4 Direction which members acknowledged and decided to accept these risks and proceed with the Direction without a 12-month consultation period. Officers acknowledge that HMOs can meet a specific accommodation need for some residents of the borough, the Direction would not prevent HMOs entirely but would allow the LPA control over their location, amenity and highway impacts etc. If the Article 4 Direction is confirmed future planning applications for small HMOs would be subject to consultation with neighbouring residents as required by national legislation. Residents would then have the opportunity to submit comments on the application with material planning considerations taken into account when determining the application. Finally, the impacts HMO’s can have are acknowledged in the cabinet report for the proposed direction and are one of the reasons for proceeding with the direction, however the direction does not prevent all HMO’s but gives the Council control over their location, and allows consideration of impacts and amenity impacts for neighbouring and future occupiers. Impact on property values are not a material consideration for this direction.
The points raised in the representations in objection to the Article 4 Direction are summarised below. A number of these objections are from developers/landlords, who are currently bringing forward small HMOs in the borough and are at various stages of build or purchase and would be impacted by the Article 4(1) Direction coming into force:
• Objection to the proposed date that the Article 4 Direction would come into effect and the consultation period.
• Impact on existing developments and transitional arrangements.
• Adequacy of evidence supporting the boroughwide direction to justify a sufficient level of harm to require the direction.
• Request for a more targeted geographical approach.
• Existing regulatory mechanisms for HMOs mean the direction is not necessary.
• Housing needs and the role of HMOs.
• The Equality Impact Assessment with the Cabinet Report was not robust and there could be impacts from the direction to groups who are likely to rely upon lower-cost shared accommodation, which require further consideration.
• Financial implications for property owners and investors.
• Some HMOs are well managed and do not cause harm to the amenity of an area.
• Change in approach since January 2026 and July 2026.
• Parking issues over exaggerated in the process.
• Request to reconsider direction and introduce in 12 months
• Compensation risks and financial impact
It is acknowledged the Article 4 Direction would not be subject to a 12-month consultation period; this is not uncommon and similar consultation periods have been carried out by other authorities in the region. Cabinet elected to proceed with the expedited consultation in full knowledge of the potential financial risks of compensation claims, as set out in the report to Cabinet in July 2026. The compensation risks would be balanced against the community impacts of delaying the Article 4 Direction for 12 months. Therefore, members were aware of the opportunity to undertake a 12 month consultation prior to bringing in the Article 4 Direction but determined not to proceed with this. Concerns for the impact on existing HMOs projects which may be in progress but not completed and could now require planning permission are acknowledged. However it is not necessarily the case that these would not be granted planning permission, just that they would require permission if the change of use has not yet occurred. Furthermore, whilst the impact on private developers and landlords, including potential financial impact is noted and respected the public benefit of confirming the Article 4 Direction is considered to outweigh the interests of private developers in this instance.
The concerns with the evidence to support the Article 4 Direction as set out in the report to Cabinet and its appendices, are noted. However, it is considered this evidence is robust to demonstrate the issues arising from HMOs in the borough to justify the need for an Article 4 Direction. Consideration was given to a targeted geographical approach to the direction (para 5.2 of the Cabinet report relates); however, it was considered this could introduce inconsistent decision-making governance and current problems may also be simply displaced to nearby neighbourhoods that are not covered by the Article 4 Direction, leading to almost immediate requests for expansions of the Article 4 Direction. It is acknowledged other regimes have some control over HMOs, but these predominately, do not take into consideration issues such as amenity impacts to neighbouring properties, over-concentration of HMOs and the impact on the character of an area etc. The other regimes mainly focus on dealing with problems arising from existing HMO's in operation when the impacts are already occurring and do not consider the appropriateness of the HMO as a planning land use in a property or an area. Therefore, it is considered the Article 4 Direction is necessary to give the Council greater control over such matters.
The needs of residents for a range of type of accommodation including HMOs is acknowledged, the Article 4 Direction would not prevent HMOs entirely but would allow the Local Planning Authority control over their location, amenity and highway impacts etc. The EIA which was an Appendix to the Cabinet Report for the proposed Article 4 Direction, is considered to be robust, it has been reviewed by all relevant Council officers. It considers the impacts of the proposed direction of a range of groups of people in the borough including those with socio-economic disadvantage. It is acknowledged there was a change of assessment on whether the Council should pursue an Article 4 Direction in regard to HMOs from the report to Cabinet on 21st January 2026 regarding the adoption of St Helens Borough Council Houses in Multiple Occupation SPD and the report to Cabinet on the proposed Article 4 Direction on 20th July 2026. Whilst the Council did not propose an Article 4 Direction at the time the SPD was adopted in January 2026, further evidence gathering undertaken during 2026 demonstrated an increasing proliferation of HMOs together with associated impacts in parts of the borough. This additional evidence informed the Cabinet decision of July 2026 to make the Article 4 Direction, which is set out in the Background Document: Context, Proposals and Evidence and Justification which formed Appendix 1 of the Cabinet report from 20th July 2026.
Finally, it is acknowledged that some HMOs are well managed and offer appropriate accommodation for some residents of the borough, the direction would not stop any new HMOs in the borough or remove existing ones. If a high-quality HMO is proposed which complies with the adopted St Helens Houses in Multiple Occupation SPD, then the HMO would likely be granted permission. However, the Article 4 Direction would give the Council control to prevent poor quality HMOs which negatively impact amenity of future occupants and neighbouring residents.
Conclusion
The cabinet report from July 2026 alongside background research shows there is a body of data and evidence that HMO development now needs planning controls in St Helens. The representations to the consultation on the direction have been considered above and do not raise issues which were not considered in the cabinet report and its evidence or raise new issues which would warrant not proceeding with confirmation of the Article 4 Direction or to make changes to Article 4 Direction approved by Cabinet in July 2026.
It is therefore appropriate to now seek a final decision to confirm the boroughwide Article 4(1) Direction from the Executive Director of Place Services (in consultation with the Cabinet Member for Regeneration, Property & Planning). It will then be necessary to inform the Secretary of State and give public notice that the Council has confirmed the Article 4(1) Direction, which will then come into force on 1st December 2026, as set out in the consultation documents for the Article 4 Direction.
Risk Implications
As detailed in the Cabinet Report, proceeding with an Article 4(1) Direction without allowing a 12 month lead in period, then there is a risk of compensation claims from property owners and/or developers who have incurred abortive expenditure or losses due to the withdrawal of permitted development rights. The level and nature of compensation is broadly unknown and will likely remain broadly unknown due to the nature of permitted development for small HMOs and the current high levels of HMOs that the borough is experiencing.
The only way to mitigate this risk would be for the Council to opt for a non-immediate Article 4 Direction, with a lead-in time of 12 months before it comes into effect, with there being no recourse to compensation after 12 months. There would however be a risk of an increase in HMOs being implemented in the 12-month period before the Article 4 Direction comes into effect, which would result in harm to the amenity of the area during that period. To mitigate the compensation risk it is proposed that a consultation process is still undertaken before confirming the Article 4 Direction, but not for a 12-month period.
The Article 4 Direction could result in a reduction in the supply of HMOs. However, the impact of an Article 4 direction is that an application to the Council for planning permission would now be required for all small HMOs. It does not mean that such applications would be refused but that they would have to be determined in accordance with the Council’s Development Plan and related planning policies.
The Secretary of State, after being notified of the Article 4 Direction, can intervene to reduce the area that the Article 4 Direction covers or can stop the Article 4 Direction completely. However, the Council believes it has a strong enough justification for the proposed Article 4 Direction as set out throughout this report and its appendices.
Measures to Redress Risk
As per the Cabinet report, a 7 week consultation period was undertaken, with comments received addressed as part of this proposal.
Declarations Of Interest
None
Equality Impact Assessment
Download
More information
Please contact Kieran Birch on 01744 676114